Joseph Franklin Executed: Last-Minute Efforts to Halt Execution Overturned by Supreme Court
"A stay is necessary to ensure that [Missouri's] last act against Franklin is not permanent, irremediable cruel and unusual punishment in violation of the eighth amendment," Laughrey wrote in her fourteen-page ruling.
Missouri quickly sought to appeal Laughrey's decision in the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals, according to the Associated Press.
via U.S. District Judge Nanette K. Laughrey
Just a few hours later, Judge Carol Jackson filed her own stay of execution, citing Franklin's claim that he is mentally incompetent to be executed, according to the St. Louis Post Dispatch.
Jackson's ruling noted that Franklin's execution had already been halted, but she added that Franklin's claims of mental incompetence deserve a separate court decision.
Franklin and twenty other inmates are challenging the constitutionality of Missouri's execution drug, which changed last month to pentobarbital after international outcry over the state's use of a common anesthesia, propofol.
But there's a problem with pentobarbital: The only place to get it is an unnamed, unregulated pharmacy, so there's no way know if the drug is contaminated or properly potent. The execution process is so secretive and elusive that Daily RFT (half-jokingly) suggested the state start using the guillotine instead.
If the pentobarbital is not clean or potent enough, Franklin and other prisoners executed with the drug could experience serious levels of pain before their deaths, say medical experts in Laughrey's ruling.
"What research [Franklin's lawyers] have produced in the little time afforded to them suggests a high risk of contamination and prolonged, unnecessary pain beyond that which is required to achieve death," Laughrey says.
Missouri overhauled its execution protocol in May and again in August, making major changes well into October before scheduling Franklin's execution for mid-November.
Given the strength of his argument and the permanent nature of the death penalty, Franklin deserves to live long enough to take his challenge to court, Laughrey writes in her ruling, offering a sharp and snarky civics lesson to Governor Nixon and state bureaucrats:
"That is how it is normally done in America, and it is a system that has worked quite well."
Read Laughrey's full ruling after the jump.