STL Cops to End World's Oldest Profession by Publicly Shaming Johns with Postcards
Since then, several other cities and police departments around the country have combined it with a media-shame campaign at one time or another. In 2012, there were 40 police departments using "Dear John" postcards. Other cities have even gotten even more creative with their public-shaming strategies.
In Baltimore County, Maryland, police there informed the suspect's entire community of his or her trial date and encouraged them to come watch. And in Corpus Christi, Texas, convicted johns had to put a "Stop Prostitution" bumper sticker on their car.
And in 2005, St. Louis tried it for a short while, to no great fanfare.
DemandForum.net, which is funded by the National Institute of Justice, says there isn't any statistical evidence that the "Dear John" postcards do any good. But they get some attention -- and they're cheap.
"As criminal-justice interventions go, Dear John letters are inexpensive, requiring just the initial drafting of the letters, and then perhaps fifteen minutes per letter to complete and less than $.50 per letter to mail," the organization's website says.
Although it's cheap and will probably dissuade at least a few potential johns, there are opponents of the practice.
Jeffrey Mittman, Executive Director of ACLU Missouri, says the public shaming policies flout a person's right to a fair trial before punishment is assessed.
"Providing a governmental notice to an individual's home where a spouse, sibling, parent, or child can see an indication that a government is alleging they're engaged in solicitation of prostitution or lascivious behavior when the individual has only been arrested is can clearly have potentially negative consequences on that family prior to that individual having been found guilty of any crime," Mittman tells us.
He adds: "The government should not be in the business of causing harm to families of individuals who have not been adjudicated and found guilty."
Another possible risk is that it causes more harm to prostitutes by pushing them further into the shadows, according to a 2001 study by the John Howard Society, a Canadian organization that deals with crime policy:
"Canadian cities that have implemented these techniques, it is believed to have had a negative effect on the prostitutes. This approach has done nothing but displace street prostitutes from one area to another, often to less visible and more dangerous areas. Violence against prostitutes also increased, as johns who were publicly humiliated, took their anger out on them."
Howard disagrees with this assessment.
"That's not a concern to me. These particular areas have been affected by prostitution for years and years," Harvey says. "I haven't seen any studies that displacing them, how that would put them in anymore danger than they are currently."
Follow Ray Downs on Twitter:
E-mail him at Ray.Downs@RiverfrontTimes.com.