Tuesday, May. 19 2009 @ 3:23PM
Dave Nelson is the author of the blog Beer, Wine and Whisky. He writes about wine for Gut Check every Tuesday.I love rosés -- perfect for picnics or just for sipping to keep cool on warm summer nights. I always end up going through a case or so each year. The 2008 vintage has begun to arrive on the market, but quantities seem to be quite small, with some wines having already come and gone.
I wanted get on top of what was available to secure my stash, so I invited a group of five friends for a rosé tasting. The wine experience of the panel varied, but all are rosé fans. Thanks to Zac, Carl, Mark, (another) Mark and Jennie for the help.
The plan was simple: Each person brought a 2008 rosé, telling us what it was to avoid duplicates. I then filled out the field with other interesting samples, including one 2007 rosé and a supermarket white zinfandel. Apart from a handful (less than, perhaps), rosés are best enjoyed fresh, and I wanted to see if a 2007 tasted noticeably old. I included the white zinfandel because we tasted the wines blind. What better way to remove any bias against white zin than tasting without seeing the label?
 |
| Wikimedia Commons |
I tasted all of the wines single-blind, meaning that I knew what wines were to be tasted, but I didn't know the order in which they were presented. My friends tasted five of the wines (the ones they brought) single-blind and four double-blind, meaning they didn't know either the identity of these wines, or the order in which they were tasted. I accomplished this by opening all of the wines, wrapping them in paper bags and placing them in the fridge myself. Another person at the tasting then pulled wines randomly from the fridge and assigned them numbers. We only revealed the identity of the wines once we had completed the tasting.
In total, we sampled nine rosés. Unfortunately, the one I was most looking forward to ended up having a significant flaw.
(My friend Mark had purchased it from Bon Vivant Wines, and
Andrew stepped up immediately to replace it with a new bottle. However, we weren't able to retaste it in time for this post, so I'll add a comment when that happens.)
We initially tasted the wines on their own, and then with a variety of rosé-friendly foods. I served some charcuterie, a nice roasted red pepper chevre spread on crostini, a basic bruschetta and falafel sandwiches.
Below are my tasting notes, with additional comments from the rest of the panel. The wines are listed from the group's favorite to its least favorite, and the first four wines are recommended.