Review + Photos: Roger Waters' The Wall Live Tour at the Scottrade Center, Friday, October 29

roger_waters_wall_front_live_2010.jpg
Todd Owyoung
Roger Waters' The Wall Live Tour at the Scottrade Center
If you're a Pink Floyd fan, Roger Waters' The Wall Live tour is a big deal: It's the first time in twenty years that the entire iconic album has been played live by someone associated with the band. Even if you're not a Pink Floyd fan, the tour is a technical marvel worth experiencing, a show full of well-choreographed special effects and arena spectacle. Last night, an adoring crowd packed the Scottrade Center for the St. Louis stop of the tour. The night was thought-provoking and visually dazzling, although occasionally flawed.

View a slideshow of photos from Roger Waters' The Wall Live Tour at the Scottrade Center

Before the show started, a homeless-looking man pushing a stuffed shopping cart wandered through the crowd. He made his way to the front of the stage and threw a faint-pink ragdoll onstage - a symbolic representation of the album's character, Pink. Soldiers carrying red flags with the familiar crossed-hammers logo marched onto the stage. The platform on which they stood then lifted them high above the stage, fireworks exploded and Waters walked out. Silver-haired and sporting sunglasses, he shrugged on a black leather jacket with the same logo on its sleeve. Thus began "In the Flesh?" a song which ended with a dynamic explosion of pyrotechnics.

The rest of the Wall experience was sensory overload, in the best possible way. Surround-sound beamed incidental voices and instrumental effects around the arena; the enveloping disorientation was effective. Moody lights bathed Waters and the band in spooky reddish-black hues. Giant inflatables - a garish caricature of a British schoolteacher, a green-hued dragon-woman with orange spiky hair and, of course, a black pig floating above the crowd - nodded to Pink Floyd's arena traditions. A circular video screen in the back complemented the projections on the jagged, in-progress wall; notable animations included plants simulating sex and planes air-dropping dollar signs, a cross, the Star of David and the Shell Oil logo. (Being able to look up at the ceiling and see the giant Volkswagen "VW" logo on the arena's hidden Jumbotron felt rather fitting.

the_wall_itself_waters.jpg
Todd Owyoung
The Wall itself. Roger Waters' The Wall Live Tour at the Scottrade Center
The wall itself was constructed methodically -- and with such pinpoint precision -- that each brick melted into part of the video screen immediately after being placed. By the end of part one, the stark white construction effectively blocked the band from the audience. During part two, the screen became a blank palette for impressive video projections -- everything from ghoulish animation and macabre sloganeering to nightmarish monsters and marching armies of crossed-hammers. Until "The Show Must Go On," most of the band stayed largely hidden - guitarist/ex-SNL musical director G.E. Smith peeked out from behind a brick to play guitar during the sufficiently creepy "Is There Anybody Out There?" and Waters settled in a mini-living room set-up with a chair, TV and lamp for "Nobody Home."

My Voice Nation Help
21 comments
Jimcynorton
Jimcynorton

I have to say it: THE MOST DISAPPOINTING SHOW OF THE YEAR: Roger Waters/The Wall in Boston 9/30/10. He is lip synching a great deal the show. This was verified for me by one of the sound men and one of the video techs. You can either believe me or not. It is already well documented on You Tube that he has done it in the past (Search Roger Waters + lip sync and you'll find them). While it was an amazing show visually, it really takes away from the show (especially when I paid over $250 for a seat). THUMBS DOWN.

joel
joel

The show was "OK", I have seen better, and yes I to thought the voice were dubbed or taped if you will. I have also seen Gilmores Pink Floyd which is way better than Waters. I am a Pink Floyd fan, and believe waters is better off doing his musicals and other music ventures he is now pursuing. Good Luck

larry
larry

I jsut saw the concert last night in Tampa. I have been a Pink Floyd fan for 20 years. I will have to say that was the best show i have ever seen. The videos were perfect, the music was perfect. Had great seats above everyone that stood on the floor.

JOHN BROWN
JOHN BROWN

Sorry youre in denial mike. But when you stand on top of the wall pretending to play with a whammy bar on a guitar that is not even equipped with one then I'd say it's deffinitely pretending. As far as Roger singing, well I think it's kinda hard to sing into the mic with arms wide open. Believe me, I feel very sorry that amazing musicians with such talent would actuallt stoop to this level of performance.

Cris
Cris

@John-The guitarist has a name, Dave Kilminster...and he doesn't "stoop'. Just go to YouTube and view some of his "interview" vids regarding this tour...the non-existant whammy bar is clearly seen ON his Fender..that his plays to perfection on "Comfortably Numb". I wish people would just do their research before posting inaccurate "reviews" that harm fans perception of an astonishing concert production....

Mike J
Mike J

John - you are so wrong. There is no prerecorded anything - the YouTube conversion process will almost always force an out-of-synch, especially when recorded with a phone or point-and-shoot camera. I know Roger. I know GE. I know Robbie. I was at the rehearsals in NJ & NY before Toronto came along, and I've seen three shows since. You owe these masters an apology - and I expect to see it soon.

chris
chris

Can I get a witness? Thanks John.

JOHN BROWN
JOHN BROWN

THIS CONCERT WAS A HUGE DISAPPOINTMENT. NOT ONLY WAS ROGER WATERS LIP SYNCING TO A SO CALLED LIVE PERFORMANCE BUT THE MUSIC ITSELF WAS ALSO PRE-RECORDED. IF YOU WATCH SOME OF THE SO CALLED LIVE VIDEOS ON YOUTUBE YOU WILL CLEARLY SEE THE GUITAR PLAYER PRETENDING TO PLAY THE SOLOS ON COMFORTABLY NUMB.I SUGGEST ANYONE THINKING OF SPENDING AN OUTRAGOUS AMOUNT OF MONEY JUST TO SEE ROGER WATERS STANDING ON A STAGE WITH A MIC TO WATCH THE VIDEOS ON YOUTUBE FIRST. DONT GET ME WRONG, I AM A HUGE PINK FLOYD FAN, BUT WHEN AN ARTIST RESIDES TO THIS TYPE OF PERFORMANCE THEN THEY'RE BETTER OFF NOT PERFORMING AT ALL. I LOVE LIVE MUSIC AND ANYTHING PRE-RECORDED IS NOT LIVE. BUT IF THATS THE TYPE OF STUFF YOUR INTO THEN I SUGGEST YOU BUY TICKETS TO GO SEE BRITNEY SPEARS! AT LEAST YOU WILL KNOW WHAT YOU WILL BE GETTING.

chris
chris

The vocals I am referring to are the lead vocals done by Waters. There were times when the microphone was nowhere near his mouth with his arms outstretched and the vocal stayed right on. Not all were faked however, but I think there was a track playing alongside at times.

Hilary
Hilary

@ Annie - Just wanted to give credit where credit was due. I didn't see their names in the article. Nothing against you, it was a very nicely written. And, I loved the song list at the end!

Annie Zaleski
Annie Zaleski

@Hilary: I've seen Venice before, including in Springfield, IL this past summer. Know exactly who they are -- please see our music feature and blogpost (linked there) interview with Kipp.

Also, I believe the faked vocals to which Chris was referring weren't the backup ones. Chris, correct me if I'm wrong.

Hilary
Hilary

@Annie, who wrote this article - The band called "Venice", who are Rogers back up singers have names. They are Pat Lennon and Kipp Lennon (who are brothers), and Mark Lennon who is their cousin. There is a fourth member of the band, "Venice", who is not on tour with Roger, and his name is Mike Lennon. They have made probably twenty albums themselves, before Roger.

@Chirs - On behalf of the band "Venice", thanks for the compliment, but, NO, the vocals aren't faked. You can check out their incredible sound and harmonies at www.venicecentral.com

They are the real thing. They are the best vocalists next to CSNY, The Beach Men (I mean BOYS), and all the rest who don't come close to their harmonies. Just sayin'...

@ Paul - the children are from the local Boys And Girls club.

Enjoy the show!

LeahG
LeahG

As a young Pink Floyd fan, and music buff, I can honestly say that out of the numerous various concerts that I have been to, this was BY FAR the best thing I have EVER SEEN! I literally sat to the left of the stage in the very top row and the show was so amazing, the seats did not matter. The music and lyrics were spot on, the pyrotechnics were amazing, as were the giant characters and I don't think any other concert could ever top this one. Thanks, Roger Waters, for making sure that someone as young as I got to see the amazing concert that was "The Wall". I can hardly express what it means to me.

Erin
Erin

Thanks to the nice gentleman who gave me his extra ticket during intermission. My original seats were on the 3rd balcony, he gave me a ticket on the first floor!! I have been a floyd fan for 15yrs. Thank you who ever you are. E.Peiffer Springfield MO

Paul
Paul

Does anyone remember where the local children's choir the performed on Another Brick, Part 2 are from?

Chris
Chris

Am I the only one that thinks that some of the vocals were faked?

Denise
Denise

I'm so glad I had a chance to see this amazing show! I'd like to thank Roger for bringing it back and sharing it with his fans, old and new. I've been lucky enough to see Pink Floyd in Iowa City, with David Gilmore, then Roger in St. Louis, and now Roger performing The Wall. All were great shows, but this one was amazing, powerful, emotional, and unforgettable. If this was his swan song, you couldn't ask for better.

Thank you Roger!!!

MG
MG

Wonderfully memorable show. Joe H - the players did come back in front of the wall, after intermission, rising out of the stage; and, there is no encore to an album played in it's entirety. Agree with AZ, Waters hyping/playing to crowd seemed out of place w/seriousness of moment, but crowd was so happy to see (to some of us)a show that we'd never think would happen, it did not matter. Selfishly, I hated to have an intermission at all, just fast-forward the break like we do with a DVR and commercials. Amazing spectacle, worth the price of admission and all the non-compliant photographers using banned flash settings :)

Brandi
Brandi

this is the best show i have ever seen in my life!!! i am so glad i got to go and see this wonderful show and the most awesome music!

Joe H
Joe H

The musick was top notch however, I was not imprssed with the wall being built.I came to see the players work their magic. Instead I cought a glimpse of them behind the wall. Did I leave to soon ?? Where was the encore

danny
danny

this was the best show i have been two in a very long time i am so glad i went to the show

Now Trending

From the Vault

 

St. Louis Event Tickets
©2013 Riverfront Times, LLC, All rights reserved.
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places St. Louis

    Voice Places

    Find everything you're looking for in your city

  • Happy Hour App

    Happy Hour App

    Find the best happy hour deals in your city

  • Daily Deals

    Daily Deals

    Get today's exclusive deals at savings of anywhere from 50-90%

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    Check out the hottest list of places and things to do around your city