Review: Menomena and Maps & Atlases at the Gargoyle, Thursday, March 10

Scott Layne
These are interesting times for Menomena. Last night's show at The Gargoyle was part of the Portland band's second tour without founding keyboardist Brent Knopf, who left the group in January. This is not an inconsequential loss; Knopf's clear, high voice complemented his ex-bandmates' raspier lower registers, and he wrote some of the group's best songs. Menomena may run more smoothly without another cook in the kitchen, but it's hard to believe they wouldn't miss the songwriting talent behind "Wet and Rusting."

View a slideshow of Menomena/Maps & Atlases at the Gargoyle

It's easier to believe they wouldn't miss Knopf on stage, however. In last October's otherwise excellent concert, Knopf played well but wore an apathetic expression that foreshadowed his departure and didn't jibe well with the rest of the band's enthusiastic stage presence. Knopf's lifeless performance also stood in stark contrast to his replacement Paul Alcott's expressive dancing. When combined with his generally sharp work on the keys and guitar, Alcott's passion made this Menomena show a looser, more-fun affair than last year's already great show.

After persevering through a wonky PA that cut in and out during opener "Strongest Man in the World," Menomena kicked into high gear with "Taos." The forceful rocker came off much better in concert than it does on Mines as Justin Harris' driving bass lines and strong vocals gave truth to his lyrics about growing more confident. Of course, everything has more kick on stage when Danny Seim is your drummer. Swaying and sweating profusely, Seim pounded out cascading beats while somehow also turning in respectable vocals. The gurgling, syncopated funk of "Weird" showed that Seim is capable of restraint, but it was such a blast to watch him go full-on Keith Moon that it was almost disappointing when he pulled back.

Scott Layne
Perhaps this is why the harder songs fared best. It also could have been the many great jagged guitar leads from Harris, Alcott or Matt Dabrowiak, depending on the song (at one point the band joked about how complicated all the instrument switching was). Harris' always-welcome bursts of sax didn't hurt either. The intensity reached fever pitch during Dabrowiak's blinding slide guitar wailing in set highlight "Bote."

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
Diana Diaz
Diana Diaz

Hey, what you don't know...Brent was very sick during that tour and had been ill for a few months. Could be the reason for the "apathetic expression"


I was at the Luminary show last October and Knopf is an understated live performer, yes, but I found his big grin throughout much of the set to be far from apathetic. He is a great player, something I noticed Alcott had to sample. I can't comment much on his musicianship because, frankly, I was too distracted by his obnoxious dancing and Sideshow Bob hair. His dancing and pointing/directing and general antics painted him as a show-off scene-stealer next to Harris and Seim. Alcott's stupidity aside, Menomena is a fantastic band and they put on a damn good show!

Now Trending

St. Louis Concert Tickets

From the Vault