Laura Jane Grace, Against Me!, and the Punk Rock Politics of Gender Identity

better-living-through-music.jpg
Art and life co-habitate, informing, imitating, and enriching each other constantly. Each week in Better Living Through Music, RFT Music writer Ryan Wasoba explores this symbiotic relationship.

Tom Gabel is dead. In March, the lead singer of Against Me! came out publicly as a transgender female. The artist formerly known as Tom Gabel is now Laura Jane Grace, and she is the first transgender person some fans of the band have ever encountered.
This specific situation is not without precedent: Synthesizer extraordinaire Wendy Carlos underwent reassignment surgery using funds from the Switched On Bach album she released in 1968 as Walter Carlos.

There are other transgender musicians, but as far as I can tell, Grace is the first since Carlos to transition after establishing a career as a male. Keeping in mind the tendency for musicians to be societal outsiders and Against Me!'s particular position on the cultural fringes as a punk band, I am surprised there has not been another modern example. I do understand why somebody struggling with gender identity would be hesitant to make such a drastic change in the public eye.

I cannot pretend to be an expert on transgender issues. I have three trans friends, and knowing their struggle has been invaluable to my understanding, just as people tend to hold an abstract view of homosexuality before they truly get to know a gay person. I know that changing genders, rebelling against your physical body, is anything but easy. It involves a level of commitment that would scare off even the most DIY, road-warrior touring bands.

I hope that folks understand that Laura Jane Grace is a rebirth and not a rebranding. Historically, males in rock who flirt with a female persona do so for attention, comedy or irony. The New York Dolls dressed in drag in the infant days of punk, but that was an empty gesture for shock value. It was as meaningless as the swastikas on Sid Vicious's shirts.

Since those days, punk rock has matured from an artform based on shock. Social justice is increasingly part of the punk agenda, and Laura Jane Grace's transition could not have come at a better time. I do not mean this is a publicity stunt, I just can't imagine a comparable figure in rock having such courage twenty years ago. Okay, maybe Guy Picciotto from Fugazi, but he is apparently okay with being a guy.
Grace's action is a reflection of our times.



Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
6 comments
Alissa Nelson
Alissa Nelson

First off, I'm glad you're writing this. I was really disappointed with some of the response among people who are ostensibly part of the punk scene in STL, who saw this as fodder for cheap jokes (looking at you, Silver Ballroom and Fister). But then it's always been a pretty sexist scene. That said, gender identity/presentation is not strictly an issue of sexuality. Not that I expect you to go into a treatise on trans issues, but this is still pretty far out of the mainstream political discussion on sexuality.

Ryan Wasoba
Ryan Wasoba

Ouch! Always Harnish with the burn. What I struggled to find proper wording for and therefor left out of the article was that Gabel and Carlos were both significant figures in music before their transitions. It isn't that Laura Jane Grace is the first since Carlos, but the highest profile transition since. I didn't want to make it seem like Jayne County or Mina Caputo were not significant or their changes were less important. The idea was that this will affect more people than those examples and will have a better chance of affecting a demographic that is unfamiliar with transgendered folks. That's all.

Matt Harnish
Matt Harnish

Look, he didn't say there weren't any other examples, he just said that as far as he could tell there weren't any other examples. Were you expecting him to do research or something? Jeez.

Jason Robinson
Jason Robinson

Throbbing Gristle's Genesis P-Oriddge and wife Lady Jaye were "becoming" Breyer P-Orridge, a "single pandrogynous entity"

Rob Wagoner
Rob Wagoner

Let's not forget Wayne County/Jayne County, the first punk rock transsexual singer, who is still performing in Atlanta to this day.

Annie Zaleski
Annie Zaleski

Life Of Agony's Keith Caputo is now known as Mina Caputo--she transitioned in recent years. Her career was well-established before her change as well.

Now Trending

St. Louis Concert Tickets

From the Vault

 

Clubs

Loading...