Comedians Are The New Rock Stars

Thumbnail image for better-living-through-music.jpg
Art and life co-habitate, informing, imitating, and enriching each other constantly. Each week in Better Living Through Music, RFT Music writer Ryan Wasoba explores this symbiotic relationship.

No phrase encapsulates the worst elements of music quite like the phrase "rock star." My disdain is so strong that, in the rare event that I consume an energy drink, I skip over Rockstar for a less delicious can of Monster simply out of principle. By the time I developed enough tastes to form a personal aesthetic, the superstar musician was a parody of a former era. Legitimate rock stars do exist today, we just call them comedians.

See also:
- The Best St. Louis Comedy Shows in January
- Stand-Up Comedy: It's Like Rock & Roll but with More Assholes
- Colorado Comedian Ben Roy's Rise and What St. Louis Can Learn From It

I have noticed a shift among those near me. Conversations previously reserved for nerding out about the new Yo La Tengo record (spoiler alert: it's excellent) are spent discussing Tig Notaro. When Radiohead came to St. Louis last year, I forgot about the show until the day after. But when Louis CK played the Fox, every human friend in town seemed to either have tickets or want tickets. People I know who complain about DIY shows costing more than five dollars had no issue shelling out forty bucks for his performance. This is because Louis CK is more of a rock star today than Thom Yorke.

The parallels between comedy and music are many. They share media outlets. Performers in both scenes increasingly tour in the same venues. In the simplest of terms, people listen to music and comedy to be entertained. The comedy experience may have fewer dimensions, as there is a direct and obvious intention to entertain by humor. Nobody can listen to a random MP3 and know their musical needs will be catered to, but I know what I am generally in for if I tune in to Comedy Central Presents Some Comedian I've Never Heard Of.

My instinct is to associate comedians with the rock star model of olden days, when the singer in the band was to be worshiped because his singular job was to entertain. I want to think that as musicians make artistic decisions that alienate fans, they humanize themselves and leave a void in fans for comedians to fill. Supply and demand. The opposite probably bears more truth. The real rock stars of comedy, the Chris Rocks and Patton Oswalts, have deeper meanings in their jokes. George Carlin's bits were no less socially relevant than Bob Dylan's songs.

No performing musician is as exposed on stage as a standup comedian. There is always an instrument or a melody to hide behind, even if the musician is using these tools to indirectly show his or her soul. We reward musicians for their abilities. Slash gets paid because he can (kind of) shred. Lady Gaga gets paid because she can (kind of) sing. We reward comedians for their unique outlooks on life. There are definite techniques to comedy, but it is an artform based on personality more than a specific skill set.

When I used to play in bands, there were rare instances where somebody would use the phrase "rock star" as a well intended compliment. I hated it. At the time, I cringed at the thought of being that guy who goes on stage just to soak up the spotlight. But also, I knew that I didn't deserve the title. The standup comedians, the ones who get in front of a microphone just to do the thing that nobody in a band ever knows how to do between songs, those are the real heroes.

Follow RFT Music on Twitter or Facebook. But go with Twitter. Facebook blows.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

"Nobody can listen to a random MP3 and know their musical needs will be
catered to, but I know what I am generally in for if I tune in to Comedy Central Presents Some Comedian I've Never Heard Of."

Comedians HATE this idealogy...Comedy Central Presents Doug Stanhope is much different than say Comedy Central Presents Greg Warren. 

"There are definite techniques to comedy, but it is an artform based on personality more than a specific skill set."

Comedians would hate this just as much. If personality was the main driver of comedy artform then the class or office clown would be billionaires...this is insulting.


Support local comedy tonight at FITZ's 6605 Delmar Boulevard, St. Louis, MO 10PM Yes they have a Late Nite Menu.

Tom Buckholz
Tom Buckholz

how much was the radiohead ticket? how much for louie? ive never seen a comedy show of just one guy, they are usually 3 or 4 acts like music shows. also, comedians CANT really tour the same material more than once and lots tend to release an album or dvd of a certain tour's material then have to retire that material and write a new hour of material for the next tour.. if people come out and hear jokes they already know. they are annoyed. (most) which is the opposite of musicians who are appreciated for, and expected to, play old stuff perhaps you are paying for that freshness of material.. but there are a lot of smaller comics who are excellent who can be seen 3 or 4 on a bill for the same price as a local music show.

Travis Bursik
Travis Bursik

Is this the right opportunity to ask how the pricing scheme for comedians can be justified? How can I see three bands for ten bucks, but this one dude on stage charges $40? There are a lot of comedians I love that come through town, but I never consider seeing them because of the price.


@Binky101 I think you're misreading. These are generalizations, yes, but in comparison to the artform of music, the different skills required, the market, et cetera. I agree that comedians are very diverse, and you can't even compare someone like David Cross to someone like Jeff Dunham. BUT the overall similarity of two men who, despite their differences, have an overall career based around humor is closer than, say, a classical oboe player and a hip hop producer. Saying "I like standup comedy," as vague as that statement might be, is more specific than saying "I like music."

My intention on the second section you quoted was this: Musicians show personality in their playing, but it's a less direct showing than somebody who's actually talking about their life experiences. If somebody doesn't like the personality displayed by a comedian, they aren't going to listen to their jokes just because their delivery and timing is right. Inversely, the technique and skill set involved in music are more in the forefront than in comedy. Again, I'm not downplaying any comedians and certainly not dogging the circuit in general. The whole piece is comparative. 

Even if it was insulting, thanks for reading

Now Trending

St. Louis Concert Tickets

From the Vault