The St. Louis Blog



Add to Technorati Favorites

Blogroll

Local Media

Music

St. Louis Sites

Unreal's Local Blogs o' the Week

Harry Potter and the Holy Bible

Wed Aug 08, 2007 at 10:48:40 AM

This post contains details about the ending of the final Harry Potter book. Consider yourself warned.

Last month Kendra Nolde, pastor at the Gethsemane Lutheran church in south St. Louis, took the pulpit and began to speak to her congregation about the final Potter book, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. However, instead of following the lead of many of her peers and warning her parishioners about the evils of witchcraft and paganism inherent in the mega-bestsellers, she began pitching ideas for a slogan that would grace the church’s sign on the corner of Hampton and Pernod.

dumbledore.jpg

The resulting reader board, pictured above, is indicative of an issue which has divided the religious community: should churches embrace or condemn the books that rival the Bible in sales? For many conservative Christians the decision is easy. As Michele Combs, a spokeswoman for the Christian Coalition of America recently told Newsday, "As a parent, I would never allow my children to read these books or watch the movies.”

In 2005 Pope Benedict XVI made headlines by saying the Potter books, “erode Christianity in the souls of young people.”

However, Nolde, who says she read the 700-plus page Deathly Hallows (in two days no less), is hardly alone in her Christian support of the Potter series. Several books have been written about the religious aspects of the series, including The Gospel According to Harry Potter: Spirituality in the Stories of the World's Favorite Seeker by Connie Neal, and Looking for God in Harry Potter by John Granger.

J.K. Rowling, author of the books, has even stated that she occasionally dons her Sunday best as a member of the Church of England. In fact, Deathly Hallows includes such biblical allusions as “Where your treasure is, there your heart will be also” – taken from the Sermon on the Mount – and, “The last enemy that shall be destroyed is death,” from First Corinthians. The phrases serve as important clues in Deathly Hallows’ plot development.

Nolde and others also point to larger Christian values such as love, friendship and self-sacrifice as evidence of Christianity in the Potter series. The latter is easily found in the book’s climax, when Potter, in a chapter suggestively titled “King’s Cross,” sacrifices his life then returns in the flesh to save the wizarding world from evil.

Whatever the case, many local Christian Schools continue to ban the Potter series from their libraries. Janet Gregory, principal at West Country Christian, says that even though the books might contain some Christian themes, she intends to keep them off the shelves to avoid any controversy.

Nolde, though, is considering incorporating Harry Potter into more church activities. “One of the things I’m thinking about for the fall is doing some kind of adult-education class,” she says, estimating that about half of her 160 parishioners are Potter readers. “Maybe we’ll look at phenomenon of Harry Potter and religious themes.”

For now, however, the message on Gethsemane’s curbside sign has changed to reflect the latest trend. It reads: “Our Church is prayer conditioned.”

-Keegan Hamilton

10 Comments:

Harry says:

Harry Potter And The Deathly Hallows eBook (PDF)

http://www.rlslog.net/harry-potter-and-the-deathly-hallows-ebook-pdf/

If the professing church would wake up to the Torah they would not embrace paganistic occultic heresy that is deadly dangerous to everyone. Read Torah and then read what you call the New Testament, holding it up to Torah, and you will find a consistent message. Repent from the ways of man and return to the Way of the Lord - Torah! Wake up church, while there's time! REPENT!!!!!!!!

Ryan says:

Excellent analysis Mr. Hamilton,

I've always found the conservative movement to ban Harry Potter puzzling. The same parents who likely allow their children to revel in Saturday morning cartoons that are taking an increasingly edgy tone as well as countless movies and television programs directed toward children that contain gun violence in one sense or another.

It seems to me that when in analyzed, guns on TV are far more dangerous and damaging. I mean, think about it if a kid picks up a 'wand', points it at you and shouts "Avada Kedavra", what's going to happen? NOTHING. Now, if that same kid picks up a gun and pulls the trigger ... What happens then?

That's all I'm saying. Rowling has created a masterpiece and a phenomenon. Christians are always quick to judge the things kids like more than Jesus. I for one think that Harry and Jesus can peacefully co-exist in today's culture, and based on everything I've read about the dude, so would Jesus.

Miriam says:

Good for you, Pastor Nolde, in standing up for truth in literature, now that it is so necessary for our children & youth. The education class is a fantastic idea. I hope it works before they shut you down ={

shawn says:

I am a Christian. I have been in church all my live. I go to church weekly. Before Harry Potter, I never have read any books. I always looked for the condensed books and usually skimmed them. I watched the movie and was interested. I heard how much better the books were, so I read the first book cover to cover. I know have read all 7 books, and plan on re-reading over the winter. I now have many more books that I have read.

I also got a wand for Christmas, and a mini statue, it is on my shelve. I never had the need to pick it up and start pointing it at things. I know the books are fiction, just like bugs bunny. I know that the coyote falling off a cliff and living would never happen in real life. I also know younger kids are the same. They can tell the difference between realities and make believe.

I also hate that people can "ban" books with out even reading them. I have read a lot of religious tones in the book. With book seven, we even have a direct quote from the bible.

There are far more dangerous things out there like drugs and drinking that mess up your mind that a book could not even compare too.

When I have kids, they get to read the books, and we will discuss the religious themes in themes in them and I will point out what is make believe. But I will not deny them the books especially if it gets them to read.

Sahar says:

Well done indeed! I agree with the other posts that anyone who as actually read the books will see the religious symbolism, imagery and outright quotations at once that fill not only the final book, but the whole series. The books (which are set in a MAKE BELIEVE world) promote values such as friendship, forgiveness, being true to yourself, and the importance of FAMILY! Things I would have the thought the Christian church would have wanted to promote as well. But then, when when has the religious right ever bothered actually researching the things they so hate? They are much more content to listen to sound bites, form their opinions, and never waver, despite any evidence thrown their way to the contrary.

Dolores Hemming says:

Comment on the Christian Analogy: Being introduced to King's Cross Train Station in the first book, "Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone", I didn't "get" the analogy between the title and why Harry's spirit went there, after the killing curse hit him. I'm glad I read the analogy made by Kendra Nolde. When Harry gives himself up to Voldemort to save his friends in this fictional story, J.K. Rowling gives readers of all ages a view of what it means to die to save others; sacrificially. The King (Christ) went to the "Cross" to die and save mankind from their sins. That is why Harry went there. And there, he chose to return to complete the task of destroying evil. He was able to live again in this fictional story. If not for Christ conquering Death, this story would never have happened. Well done!

Cathy says:

Lovely. It's nice to hear a Pastor saying what I've been saying for years. That Harry is far from being Evil. There are many great quotes from the books and movies that can teach people alot. Like the following:

It does not do to dwell on dreams and forget to live, remember that."

"Call him Voldemort, Harry. Always use the proper name for things. Fear of a name increases fear of the thing itself."

"Your mother died to save you. If there is one thing Voldemort cannot understand, it is love. He didn't realize that love as powerful as your mother's for you leaves its own mark. Not a scar, no visible sign ... to have been loved so deeply, even though the person who loved us is gone, will give us some protection forever. (...) It was agony to touch a person marked by something so good." (PS17)

I could go on forever, and yes there's lots of it. And to the woman who said. "As a parent, I would never allow my children to read these books or watch the movies.”

I say, "Poor Children."

Paula says:

Well done, Kendra. Nice name, too! I am glad many Christians are finally realizing there is so much to commend in this book series. Rational people, kids too, know this is a WORK OF FICTION. That means none of the spells actually work, Rowling made them up!

The wizarding world is just a background to the story, a tale of love, friendship, loyalty and doing what's right, not what's easy (to paraphrase Dumbledore).

God gave us brains so we can think for ourselves, question and discuss. Too many narrow minded people want us to follow blindly. I will never do that. And I am sorry for those who do.

Church says:

I'm a Christian and I have watched all the parts of Harry Potter and its wonder watching those movies and amazing while reading Potter books and thanks for the good review of ending of the final harry Potter Book.

Post a comment

Comments may not show up immediately after submission. Please wait a minute after posting a comment for it to appear.




Riverfront Times Insiders

  • Local food, music and news blasts
  • Free Stuff