Stlog




Add to Technorati Favorites

Blogroll

Local Media

Music

St. Louis Sites

Unreal's Local Blogs o' the Week

St. Louis Gets a Grand Central Station (Sort Of)

Tue Mar 25, 2008 at 03:38:49 PM

On Friday nights or Saturday mornings in the wee small hours, you can usually find me down at the Amshack on 16th Street waiting for the late train from Chicago. Or, rather, waiting for one particular passenger to alight from said train. It's not an especially pleasant place to pass the time: It's cold and dreary with aggressively yellow lighting. It smells weird. There are puddles on the bathroom floor. Everyone sits stiffly, either because the seats are so uncomfortable or because they are afraid they will be mugged. I've spent happier hours waiting around hospital emergency rooms.

A farewell to Amshack -- almost.

And I am not alone. In the words of Marc Magliari of Amtrak media relations, “We're looking forward to staging bulldozer races to knock down the existing Amshack.” (This is, according to Amtrak official Ray Lang, one of the funniest things ever said by an Amtrak employee.)

Which is why, despite all the grumblings about the inefficiency of Amtrak itself, the opening of the new Gateway Transportation Center just a few hundred yards east of the Amshack is anticipated with such joy. So much joy, in fact, that although the center is still not entirely finished, Amtrak invited state officials to travel on a special train from Jefferson City yesterday afternoon for a special preview of the new center. (It was supposed to be open by now, but when -- aside from yesterday when government officials were involved -- has Amtrak ever run on time?)

By Aimee Levitt

The $20 million Gateway Transportation Center is no Union Station, but it's a lovely space. In addition to Amtrak, it will host Greyhound, MetroLink and MetroBus. It has high ceilings, and the windows, although multicolored, let in lots of light. There are separate windows for ticketing and baggage. The chairs are comfortable enough. St. Louis comptroller Darlene Green, whose agency supervises the facility, has promised food concessions: Arch City Deli has already signed a contract and KFC and Pizza Hut Express are pending. Most important, the new center will have 24-hour security.

By Aimee Levitt

But it soon became apparent that pride in the new transportation center was not the only reason Amtrak invited the politicians to St. Louis. The number of Amtrak riders is increasing everywhere across the country -- except along the St. Louis-Kansas City corridor. “We cannot run the service in a reliable, dependent manner,” said Amtrak's Lang, “and on-time performance is the most important factor for customers.”

Lang blames Amtrak's poor performance in Missouri on railway lines that are already congested with freight trains. (Union Pacific, which owns the tracks, has promised to invest in improvements to the route.)

“People have shown they will not ride a service they cannot depend on,” said Brian Weiler, multimodal operations director for the Missouri Department of Transportation (MoDOT). “The number of riders decreases, the revenue from ticket sales decreases, and the subsidy Amtrak requires from the government to keep going increases. In the next two or three years, if we continue down this path, the service will go away.”

That is, if the Missouri state legislature doesn't vote to allocate Amtrak more funding.

A riddle: If a train that nobody rides goes away, will anybody miss it?

But MoDOT shouldn't be too down on itself: the Chicago-St. Louis train is usually late, too.

-Aimee Levitt

Category: Community, News

14 Comments:

thomas comeau says:

I rode the train from STL to KCY after being bussed by amtrak from Dallas to STL. My wife and I have ridden it a number of times in the last two years. Missouri needs longer sidings so freight trains can pull over and let amtrak through. I hope our legislature is more forward looking then I think it will be.

Mike Schafer says:

Will anyone miss Amtrak if it goes away? I certainly will. Having given up flying in 1982 owing partly to medical reasons, I use Amtrak frequently. In fact, my company's home office is in Kansas City, and I use Amtrak frequently from my satellite office in northern Illinois, using Amtrak's Chief from Mendota, Illinois, to K.C.. I also travel frequently to the St. Louis area, although I must confess I have chosen to avoid using the K.C.-St. Louis service because of Union Pacific's inability to move Amtrak trains across that route. And lest you think that no one rides Amtrak now... on my most recent business trip to K.C. and St. Louis (March 11-14), some of the trains were sold out, forcing me to drive (geez, I-70 is in awful shape and packed with traffic!) And about that comment about Amtrak being inefficient... Amtrak subsidies are about 20%; most international rail passenger carriers like Japanese National Railways require about 40-60% subsidies... which means Amtrak is one of the most efficient major rail passenger carriers in the world.--Mike Schafer

Adron says:

The only way I'd be happy if Amtrak went away, is if the private sector would take it back or the individual states. In fact I'd be damn happy if they went away and we go better, operationally, service oriented, functional, and timely train service. But I digress, the nation has become filled with too many mooches and winers for that to ever happen again.

But I digress, if "passenger service" went away totally, I'd just move out of the country. It would be the greatest failing the nation has ever made.

I currently live in Portland Oregon, where I commonly enjoy trips to San Francisco and even Seattle on a very regular basis. I wouldn't even dream of flying (to Seattle it actually takes LONGER to fly than to take the train).

Love the trains, just wish the service was more reminiscient of the Burlington, Santa Fe, or Great Northern. Once can dream right. :)

happy amtrak rider says:

I ride Amtrak quite a bit and I must agree with the comments about the numerous and long delays between st. louis and KC. I love Amtrak. I also spend a lot of time at Kirkwood Station watching the trains and listening to the train frequencies on my radio scanner. Union Pacific owns the tracks between KC and St. Louis and it is a damn shame to see UP trains running at least every half hour, while at the same time forcing Amtrak trains to wait (and WAIT and WAIT) for UP trains to clear the tracks. Longer sidings will not help if UP refuses to give Amtrak the right of way. I don't know what the answer is. If longer sidings are the answer, then there is the risk that UP will drag their heels in building them. Right now Amtrak is forced to bus the St Louis to KC route frequently because of UP freight train congestion. Just yesterday, the eastbound Amtrak from KC was at least two hours late arriving into Kirkwood because of reported UP freight congestion, yet I saw UP freight trains going eastbound at least every 30 minutes.... very frustrating to those who need to make connections.

happy amtrak passenger (yes, I do love Amtrak) says:

I want to add one more comment more pertinent to the blog subject, about the new Amtrak station in downtown St. Louis.

My first impression of the new station, having been there two weeks ago to pick up my paper tickets for an upcoming very long cross country train tour, was very disappointing. The new station was still under construction, yet open to passengers, and already looks old and dingy. At least it hasn't yet acquired that lovely smell of pee that the "old" Amshack had.
Additionally, apparently nobody thought about where passengers were going to park while construction was still underway, because the only parking lot within easy walking distance of the station (for people with luggage) is still not paved and it is absolutely choked with construction vehicles. They waited thirty some odd years to build a new station - why couldn't they have made the new one a little nicer and give the construction crews time to finish the job before making Amtrak passengers share that tiny parking lot with a bunch of construction equipment?

Anna says:

I just took the train from downtown to Washington MO and the train was on time & pleasant experience the whole way with no delays. However, the train from Washington to STL was delayed an hour & a half due to freight trains. The station downtown isn;t as bad as I thought it would be (compared to Greyhound stations), but what a horrible place to come out if you are visiting STL! That would make my entire perception of our city so bad. I can't believe that the city of St. Louis has allowed that. Unlit, unpaved and very muddy parking lot congested with construction vehicles. The new station doesn;t look good-I really don;t understand why they didn;t open Union Station! Great first impression to visitors and I think Union Station could really use it.

Patrick Richmond says:

I am a railfan and a service ambassador for Metro. Amtrak's schedule is at the mercy of UP's stupidity. I remember when Norel Pride was in charge of Missouri and Illinois trains, he was one strict man. So was former Amtrak CEO David Gunn. Norel told me at one time that he was about ready to take freight operations away from UP and give them to Burlington Northern Santa Fe, due to that BNSF is a very kind freight railroad. When BNSF hears a dispatch coming over the radio about a late Amtrak train, BNSF dispatches their trains into the siding to let Amtrak pass and make up for loss time. The bi-level Superliners are a plus due to that with the lower level seating, they are ADA compatible. That saves Amtrak money due to no lifts to repair.

Patrick Richmond says:

I am a railfan and a service ambassador for Metro. Amtrak's schedule is at the mercy of UP's stupidity. I remember when Norel Pride was in charge of Missouri and Illinois trains, he was one strict man. So was former Amtrak CEO David Gunn. Norel told me at one time that he was about ready to take freight operations away from UP and give them to Burlington Northern Santa Fe, due to that BNSF is a very kind freight railroad. When BNSF hears a dispatch coming over the radio about a late Amtrak train, BNSF dispatches their trains into the siding to let Amtrak pass and make up for loss time. The bi-level Superliners are a plus due to that with the lower level seating, they are ADA compatible. That saves Amtrak money due to no lifts to repair.

Patrick Richmond says:

I am a railfan and a service ambassador for Metro. Amtrak's schedule is at the mercy of UP's stupidity. I remember when Norel Pride was in charge of Missouri and Illinois trains, he was one strict man. So was former Amtrak CEO David Gunn. Norel told me at one time that he was about ready to take freight operations away from UP and give them to Burlington Northern Santa Fe, due to that BNSF is a very kind freight railroad. When BNSF hears a dispatch coming over the radio about a late Amtrak train, BNSF dispatches their trains into the siding to let Amtrak pass and make up for loss time. The bi-level Superliners are a plus due to that with the lower level seating, they are ADA compatible. That saves Amtrak money due to no lifts to repair.

Patrick Richmond says:

I am a railfan and a service ambassador for Metro. Amtrak's schedule is at the mercy of UP's stupidity. I remember when Norel Pride was in charge of Missouri and Illinois trains, he was one strict man. So was former Amtrak CEO David Gunn. Norel told me at one time that he was about ready to take freight operations away from UP and give them to Burlington Northern Santa Fe, due to that BNSF is a very kind freight railroad. When BNSF hears a dispatch coming over the radio about a late Amtrak train, BNSF dispatches their trains into the siding to let Amtrak pass and make up for loss time. The bi-level Superliners are a plus due to that with the lower level seating, they are ADA compatible. That saves Amtrak money due to no lifts to repair.

Patrick Richmond says:

I hope that they hire senior citizens for the food service work. They can be talented and quite strong. Why run the risk of being fined of thousands of dollars for age discrimination when it is best to save and abide by the rules. Age is just a number. But talent is a gift from God! I can hardly wait until I set foot on the escalator.

Jim says:

I'm glad that junky joke that they call "Amtrak" is finally being demolished. It's the world's worst shack, and nobody would even believe that it's actually there to get on trains, because it looks more like a ghost shack by train tracks than a train station. This new one is awesome, though. I've seen the new one in person. I live in the St. Louis area. We've never had a very good transportation system ever since Union Station shut down in 1966, before I was born.

Jim says:

Please don't get me wrong, here. I love Amtrak, I don't have anything against it, it's just that the station in St. Louis is a junkyard. Maybe someday Union Station will become a station again...doubtfully. I hope Amtrak becomes more popular now that car gas prices are getting so high. People would rather pay a few bucks for a ticket than nearly $5.00/gallon.

GBearFan says:

It's August now. So, when is this thing gonna open?

Post a comment

Comments may not show up immediately after submission. Please wait a minute after posting a comment for it to appear.




Riverfront Times Insiders

  • Local food, music and news blasts
  • Free Stuff